I have long wondered about the concept of choice when it comes to obesity. Suggestions offered for those who want to lose weight generally center around things that require motivation.
For example, as a diabetic, I must maintain an adequate level of sugar in my system. Thus, exercise can be a double-edged sword because too much exercise can lead to lowered sugar, requiring consumption of additional calories.
I personally attack this problem by often eating right before exercise, taking less insulin (a hormone which can, in too great amounts, lower sugar to dangerous levels). But that doesn't mean you won't walk out of the gym with your sugar too low (in the event you have a really good workout). Or, you might miscalculate and end up with high sugar. That requires extra insulin, which can sometimes lead to low sugar later (and the need to eat extra food). It's a vicious cycle.
But exercise is also important for people with diabetes because we're at greater risk from high blood pressure, heart disease, etc.
So I see all the advice offered to people who are heavy and I wonder just how easy it is to follow. Because I know from personal experience that I do not want to be overweight. So it seems to me that someone who would prefer to be thin isn't going to 'want' to be overweight — and if there was a way to get thin, the person would. In other words, I often doubt that motivation is the problem. Rather, I've often thought that some sort of underlying biological problem might be a cause.
And here's a tidbit of evidence to support my thoughts, although I confess it's an animal study and animal studies often do not translate easily to human application.
The National Institutes of Health now suggests that obesity might cause behaviors similar to drug addiction.
"Some of the same brain mechanisms that fuel drug addiction in humans accompany the emergence of compulsive eating behaviors and the development of obesity in animals, according to research funded by the National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA)," the NIH quotes one of its institutes as saying.
The scientific journal Nature Neuroscience carries an article about the topic.
"When investigators gave rats access to varying levels of high-fat foods, they found unrestricted availability alone can trigger addiction-like responses in the brain, leading to compulsive eating behaviors and the onset of obesity," the NIH announcement says.
This makes so much sense to me because I used to crave cheese curds, bacon and fried foods (probably not the best diet for a diabetic). But when I began eating more and more fruits and vegetables and virtually abandoned greasy snack foods, suddenly I found myself craving salads, oranges and celery. Yum!
Of course, the concept isn't proved just because my own personal tastes changed. And one study in rats doesn't prove the concept either. Still, it's intriguing.
If you really want to lower your caloric intake, it might be more useful to find a way to separate yourself from fatty foods long enough to break the 'addiction' than to try various diets.
The NIH quotes Dr. Nora D. Volkow as saying, "drug addiction and obesity are two of the most challenging health problems in the United States. This research opens the door for us to apply some of the knowledge we have gathered about drug addiction to the study of overeating and obesity."
What's already been learned about drug addiction and obesity? Both are linked to "a dysfunction in the brain’s reward system." Over time, the NIH says, craving for more and more of the drug or food occurs because the "reward threshold" increases, meaning it takes more and more of the addictive drug — or food — to overcome the craving.
"The study titled: 'Addiction-like reward dysfunction and compulsive eating in obese rates: Role for dopamine D2 receptors,' by Paul M. Johnson and Paul J. Kenny in Nature Neuroscience can be found online at: http://www.nature.com/neuro/journal/vaop/ncurrent/index.html," the NIH announcement says.
Mayo Clinic offers healthy meal options online, including submitted menu items like crispy potato skins (baked in the oven, rather than fried), black bean burgers and white chicken chili. I look forward to learning what researchers continue to find.
Pulse on Health
By Jeff Hansel, member Association of Health Care Journalists
Health Reporter for the Post-Bulletin newspaper, 18 1st Ave. S.E. in Rochester, Minnesota 55904
Twitter Hansel's Pulse: @Jeff Hansel
Recent Comments