PHERSY: OK Feldy, we're only two days away from your favorite day of the year -- the NFL draft.
Your favorite team has the No. 22 overall pick. So Feldy, who do you think the Vikings take at No. 22. I'll take my thoughts (and my mean words) for after you respond.
Much of the day today there were reports surfacing about the Vikings being interested in Florida WR Percy Harvin. Rumor has it that Chili even flew down to Florida to speak with Harvin. That's kind of been the latest draft buzz around Winter Park. It should make for an interesting Saturday.
So Feldy, if you're the GM, who are you taking with the No. 22 pick? And how about in the second round?
• • •
FELDY: I don't actually stink. It's those shoes Phersy left under his desk.
Right off the bat, we're going to disagree on this one, Phersy. I would be fine with the Vikes taking Harvin at 22. The elephant in the room, of course, is his failed marijuana test at the NFL scouting combine. No excuse for that. None whatsoever. That's a stupid, stupid decision on Harvin's part. But ... I would bet my house and Phersy's house that Harvin isn't the first NFL-bound player to smoke pot. Again, not that it's OK, but I'm just sayin' ... (royalties go to Greg Sellnow for those last three words).
Now, we hear he's a bit of a bad teammate. Ever heard of Cris Carter? The guy was the biggest horse's-Favre I've ever seen. He'll also be in the Hall of Fame 'cuz all he did was catch touchdowns. There are enough veterans in the Vikings locker room to squash Harvin's head if he gets out of line.
The potential upside for this guy, to me, offsets the potential downside. It would be different if the Vikings were picking at, say, No. 7, where they got Adrian Peterson two years ago. But they're picking at No. 22, where it's far more permissible to take a gamble. Remember the uproar when they picked Randy Moss? They got him at No. 21.
Harvin would give this team something it badly needs: Another playmaker. Plus, he can return kicks and punts. If he's there at 22, I will absolutely be screaming at the screen in my war room for the Vikings to take him. The bottom line with this club is, it's getting older. The window of opportunity to advance deep in the playoffs is shrinking. They NEED a playmaker like Harvin.
All of that said, I think the Vikes will actually red-dot Harvin and take a tackle, probably Eben Britton. Either way, this draft is deep at tackle and receiver, and the Vikes could come back either way in Round 2, or I'd also be fine with them trading down, stockpiling some more mid-round picks (we gave up our 4th-rounder to Houston for Sage Rosenfels) and getting a guy such as Oklahoma OT Phil Loadholt, or Ohio State WR Brian Robiskie.
• • •
PHERSY: Old shoes? No Feldy, you do actually stink. The guys in the office have been trying to figure out a way to tell you, and I figured this was as good as any.
And you are right Feldy, we're going to disagree on this one ... big time!
So now Percy Harvin is Randy Moss??? Come on. Percy Harvin is NOT Randy Moss. He's not even close to Randy Moss.
And the biggest difference here (aside from skill, speed, hands, size) is health. Yes, both Moss and Harvin had off-the-field issues. But Harvin has some serious health concerns. Harvin is talented, there's no doubt. But if that talent isn't on the field, then what good is it.
The NY Daily News is reporting that there is a hole in one of the bones in Harvin's foot, and that will require more surgery. He's had several injuries in his college career, and he's already had multiple surgeries.
The failed drug test is another mess. I mean, you know you're going to be tested at the combine, which in my mind means he just didn't care.
How many red flags do you need Feldy? This guy has been a punk at every step of the way, high school through college and right up until the combine, and he's also had injury problems. Yet you want to use a first-round pick on him?
I don't get it. Everything about Harvin screams bust. So I think the Vikings need to pass on him in the first round. There's no question there is upside there, and if he stays healthy and out of trouble, there's a chance he could develop into a top-end NFL receiver. But there are too many ifs. Taking a receiver in the first round is one of the biggest gambles an NFL team can make (right up there with QB). It's just not worth it. I'm not saying the Vikings won't do it (I mean, this team has done crazier things), but if I'm the GM, I stay away.
The safe pick is Britton. If he's sitting there at No. 22, the Vikings need to grab him. Feldy's guy Ryan Cook has proven he's not a starting tackle in the NFL, so the Vikings need a guy who can step in right away. I think Britton is that guy. Maybe they can move Cook back to center and he can compete with Sullivan for the starting spot this season.
One thing is for sure ... draft experts are all over the place on who they have the Vikings taking. I've seen many going with Harvin or Britton, but others have said Rutgers WR Kenny Britt, Kansas State QB Josh Freeman, Connecticut CB Darius Butler, Oregon C Max Unger and Illinois CB Vontae Davis. And there are many more names out there. I'm not sure if it's just that the Vikings are a crazy team or if these "draft experts" know nothing. Probably a little of both. One recent mock I read had Jeremy Maclin slipping all the way down to No. 22. If that happens, I'd love to see the Vikings go that way, even though I'm not a fan of taking WRs in Round 1. Of course, that won't happen, but we can dream.
If you're looking for Mock Draft central, check out this Web site ... mock draft database. They have so many mock drafts, it will make your head spin.
•••
PHERSY: OK, well this is where Feldy should be typing ... but I just had an idea (yeah, I know, first time for everything).
Feldy wants the Vikings to take Percy Harvin with that No. 1 pick. If you're so set on a receiver, why not offer that first-round pick to Arizona for Anquan Boldin? I'd say he's a sure bet compared to Harvin. If the Vikings are really set on getting a WR, then why not make this move or at least try to make this move? Very little risk. Yes, you have to pay Boldin, but you already know he can be a top-end receiver in the NFL. And he hasn't tested positive for taking any bong rips lately, at least that I know of.
Seems like a no-brainer to me. Feldy, you'll have to explain to me why this move isn't much more attractive than your new man crush, Percy Harvin.
•••
FELDY: Oh boy, so many words put into my mouth by Phersy, so little time to respond.
Randy Moss? I didn't say he's the next Randy Moss, but he is unquestionably a playmaker, which again is exactly what this team needs. Phersy you're OK with Britton, the "safe pick." This team doesn't need a safe pick, doesn't have time for a safe pick, it needs someone to make the passing game a bigger threat. We obviously can't trust Sidney Rice and Bobby Wade is, well, Bobby Wade.
If the Vikes decide to take Britton at 22, I'm cool with that. It's obvious the Purple needs a tackle; I just think there are enough good tackles in this draft that they can find one in Round 2.
As for Boldin, I wouldn't be against that trade. He is more of a sure bet than Harvin, but the Cardinals are looking for a Roy Williams-type trade (remember, he went to Dallas for a first, a third and a sixth) because Boldin is a better receiver. Let's say the Cards asked for a first and a third for Boldin. Do you really want to keep mortgaging the team's future by giving up high draft picks, for a receiver who is 30 years old this season? ... I know I just said this team needs to win now, but if it keeps giving up first round picks it's going to become the Detroit Lions in three or four years.
On top of that, Boldin isn't exactly Mr. Team Leader. I'm fully aware his red flags aren't nearly as numerous as Harvin's, but what do you make of Bolding pouting, showering and leaving the locker room without celebrating just minutes after his team MADE IT TO THE SUPER BOWL!?! That smacks of selfishness.
If the Vikes are going to pursue a trade for a receiver, I'd rather see them make a run at Braylon Edwards from Cleveland.
I will agree with you on one more thing, Phersy: My head is definitely spinning as to who the Vikes will take after reading through all the mock drafts out there. Harvin, Britton, Britt, Butler, Unger, Davis ... you could make compelling arguments for drafting any of those guys, and I wouuldn't be upset with any of them. It's just that I want Harvin. That said, I would be somewhat upset if the Vikings traded up to get him. I'd prefer to see them stat at No. 22 or move down, because there are so many good players in this draft at positions they need to fill.
And I'll give you this, Phersy: If Harvin is the selection; Childress, Rick Spielman and Zygi Wilf better hold a public bonfire to burn that "Culture of Accountability" book, or whatever it is that they have at Winter Park. They can't ever use that term again, and, in all honesty, it should have been stricken from their vocabulary after Dwight Smith's incident and Bryant McKinnie's (and signing Fred Evans).
***
PHERSY: Feldy, you're talking out of both sides of your mouth. You say the Vikings are built to win now. What makes you so sure Harvin can help the Vikings win now? What makes him special? He never had a 1,000-yard receiving season in college, and you totally skipped over his injury history. Honestly, that's what concerns me most. He's dinged up, always! And with the latest reports, he may need more surgery before the Vikings even open camp.
Harvin's injury problems should concern people above all else. But on top of that, why are we all so sure he's going to be a great NFL player? He's only 5-foot-11, and yes, he's fast. I watched Harvin play maybe nine or 10 times in his college career. He's a nice receiver. But he's not Michael Crabtree. Harvin had just two 100-yard receiving games this season, and he caught a total of three passes over his team's final four regular-season games (of course, he was hurt during that time ... again). His best college season was his sophomore year, when he had a little more than 800 yards receiving and four receiving TDs.
He's never put up unreal numbers, like Crabtree or other elite receivers.
So let's just assume Harvin will be healthy and stay out of trouble, why will he be a stud in the NFL? How many rookie receivers make an impact? Very few, and there seems to be nothing to indiciate Harvin will be that guy. If the Vikings are set up to win now, then why not trade for an established receiver, as opposed to drafting a guy who has a little potential?
I will be seriously upset if the Vikings take Harvin at No. 22 today. Hopefully someone else will take the risk and draft him before Chili and the boys have the chance to make the mistake.
Get a tackle, solidify the line and let's see what these boys can do!
Recent Comments